Old-School Restaurants · verified Jul 15, 2026 · By Piyush Puri
Best Old-School Restaurants in Brooklyn
The 10 best old-school restaurants in Brooklyn for 2026, from Peter Luger and Di Fara to Gage & Tollner, all verified open and still worth the trip today.
The map
Loading the map
- 1Williamsburg · $$$$ · 178 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Also No. 1 on Best of Williamsburg →
A Williamsburg steakhouse that has been dry-aging beef under the same roof since 1887, making it the third-oldest steakhouse in the city. The room still runs on bare wooden tables, career waiters with zero patience for indecision, and a porterhouse that lands sizzling in its own butter.
No restaurant in Brooklyn carries more weight, and the porterhouse ritual still feels like something you inherit rather than order.
Porterhouse for two, ordered for one less than your party size, with creamed spinach and German fried potatoes
